Over 60% of Health Committee members have previously opposed assisted dying

Seven of the 11 members of the Health and Social Care Select Committee have previously opposed assisted dying, with only three being known to be supportive. Last month the Committee launched an inquiry on assisted dying. Humanists UK has said it is vital that the Committee takes a careful, balanced look at the evidence, and listens to those who want an assisted death and their loved ones.

Four of the eleven members have voted against assisted dying in the past, including the Committee’s Chair Steve Brine, although it is unknown if this is still all of their positions. Three other members have previously told Humanists UK or their constituents that they are opposed, although again their positions may have changed since. At any rate, this contrasts with 93% of the public being in support, according to a 2019 poll.

At least three of the members of the Committee (27%) have also voted against abortion rights. 86% of the public support women’s right to an abortion, with just 5% opposed.

The Committee is also much more religious than the public at large: only one of the 11 MPs (9%) affirmed upon entry into Parliament (i.e. made a non-religious oath), with the other ten swearing a Christian oath. This compares with 24% of all MPs having affirmed. The 2019 British Social Attitudes Survey recorded that 53% of British adults belong to no religion.

The makeup of the Committee changed extensively towards the end of 2022, in part due to the frequent changes of ministers in Government. MPs that are promoted to ministerial levels cannot take part in committees. This includes the previous Committee Chair, Jeremy Hunt, who first brought the inquiry onto the Committee’s agenda.

In January David Gauke, the former Justice Secretary, expressed concern about the makeup of the Committee. He wrote in an article for the New Statesman ‘The composition of the committee makes it very unlikely that it will recommend reform’.

Assisted Dying Campaigner Nathan Stilwell said:

‘We welcomed this inquiry when it was announced on the understanding that it would listen to the voices of people who are dying and their families and would examine the evidence, particularly from around the world.

‘The British public cares deeply about this issue so it is vital that the Committee produces a well-researched, unbiased report.’